Gajendra Thakur
Era Before and After - Literary scene in Maithili after the arrival of Jagdish Prasad Mandal
Issue No. 88
(November-December 2019) of Muse India at
http://museindia.com/ displays
Maithili literature in an extremely poor light. Moreover, it wrongly
claims to be a representative review of Maithili Literature, whereas it
was only in line with the Sahitya Akademi, Delhi; a mere representation
of the so-called "dried main drain". It is expected that Muse India will
correct itself by announcing an issue exclusively devoted to the
parallel tradition of Maithili literature.- Editor
T.K. Oommen writes in the
"Linguistic Diversity" Chapter of "Sociology", 1988, page 291, National
Law School of India University/ Bar Council of India Trust book: "... the
Maithili region is found to be economically and culturally dominated by
Brahmins and if a separate Maithili State is formed they may easily get
entrenched as the political elite also. This may not be to the liking
and advantage of several other castes, the traditionally entrenched or
currently ascendant castes. Therefore, in all possibility, the latter
groups may oppose the formation of a separate Maithili state although
they also belong to the Maithili speech community. This type of
opposition adversely affects the development of several languages."
T.K. Oomen further writes: "... even when a language is pronounced to be distinct from Hindi, it may be treated as a dialect of Hindi. For example, both Grierson who undertook the classic linguistic survey of India and S. K. Chatterjee, the national professor of linguistics, stated that Maithili is a distinct language. But yet it is treated as a dialect of Hindi". (ibid, page 293)
Do not judge each day by the harvest you reap but by the seeds that you plant. - Robert Louis Stevenson
...
Videha: Maithili Literature Movement
Vidyapati of Parallel Tradition- Sketch by Videha Samman recipient Sh. Panaklal Mandal
Parallel Literature in Maithili and Videha Maithili Literature Movement
Pseudo-criticism in Maithili and the case of Kamalananda Jha
The title of Kamalanand Jha's book "Maithili Novel: Time, Society and Questions" (2021) is misleading. It is a collection of some syndicated so-called critical articles on some of his caste novelists. The 263-page book can only be sold in hardbound to libraries where it will rot. Here is a correction, a non-caste writer's work, i.e., Subhash Chandra Yadav's novel 'Gulo', has been dealt with by him in two lines, of course without reading it. I am presenting those two lines here for your entertainment. You must have read Gulo, if you haven't already, read it first because then you will have a more entertaining experience. Gulo is available on Videha Archive with the permission of Subhash Chandra Yadav at this link http://videha.co.in/pothi.htm.
"The weakness of the novel is the author's political bias. The partisanship towards a particular politics does not do justice to the work."
In a novel where politics is not remotely involved, there is no question of 'political bias and partisanship of a particular politics'. Dhumketu and Yatri used political bias or partisanship. Subhash Chandra Yadav's 'Vote' which came out in 2022 and is available with permission of Subhash Chandra Yadav on Videha Archive at this link http://videha.co.in/pothi.htm, is on politics but even there Subhashji's enchanting style obviates the need of any political bias... Read my book 'Nit Naval Subhash Chandra Yadav' which is available at this link http://videha.co.in/pothi.htm. On the other hand, Mr Kamlanand Jha sounds like a spokesperson of some political party or a casteist organisation rather than a literary critic. Kamalananda Jha's Brahministic bias against Subhash Chandra Yadav is an alarm bell. The parallel stream is conscious of how Kamalananda Jha takes the leftist stance to promote Brahminism and wants to sacrifice social justice. In his biodata, he proudly mentions the Maithili translation assignment bestowed on him by the Sahitya Akademi, and this assignment was allotted to him not on account of merit but solely on the ground of his caste title and in lieu of these deeds. For people like him, Maithili-related work is merely a line in their curriculum vitae, but it is a question of life and death for the people of the parallel stream. Why did I call Kamalananda Jha a pseudo-critic? Because he is a pseudo-critic. He writes: "After nearly a hundred years of journey, Gaurinath is credited with writing a dignified novel on the dreams, struggles and ironies of inter-caste marriage. So, did Kamalananda Jha take away this credit from Sushil? Is this the culmination of the arrogance of his Brahministic upbringing ("Through my whims and fancies I can place some literature on top and can downgrade some to the bottom") or is this the evidence of his lack of study? Let me take you away from the selfish world of Kamalananda Jha, away from deception and disguise to the sincere world of Sushil's magical literature. Welcome to the world of Sushil's literature. Here is Sushil's 'Gambali' (1982) which is now available in the Videha Archive at the link http://videha.co.in/pothi.htm. In the first line of this novel, even before the novel begins, Sushil writes about the novel 'Gambali': "In support of widow marriage and inter-caste marriage" and here begins the novel. The death of a village woman and then the trouble ensues, who will cremate this village woman? Brahmin community or Yadav community of the village? Dinesh Kumar Mishra's 'Dui Patan Ke Bich Me' is a historical biography of the Kosi River. He has also written historical biographies of other rivers of Mithila like 'Bandini Mahananda,' 'Bagmati Ki Sadgati!', 'Dui Patan Ke Bich Me... (Story of the Kosi River)', Na Ghat Na Ghar, Kamla River, 'Bhutahi River and Technical Herbalism', The Kamla River and People on Collision Course, Bhutahi Balan- Story of a Ghost River and Engineering Witchcraft, Refugees of the Kosi Embankments. Pankaj Jha Parashar, a member of the Maithili Advisory Committee of the Sahitya Akademi, Delhi has plagiarised paragraph after paragraph from his books and has published a novel in Maithili in his name, which pseudo-critic Kamalananda Jha mentions as research of this thief author Pankaj Jha Parashar! Let me clarify here that both the thief writer and the pseudo-critic are in the Hindi department of Aligarh Muslim University. This research is done by Dinesh Kumar Mishra, who is a graduate of IIT, Kharagpur in Civil Engineering (in 1968) and M. Tech in Structural Engineering (in 1970) and is qualified for that research. In Hindi, the cut-off for admission is the lowest across universities, otherwise, Kamalananda Jha would have known that this research could be done by a civil engineer only. The Hindi original and Maithili screenshots are attached below. Dinesh Kumar Mishra is not from Mithila, but he has authored the story of all the streams of Mithila. We are grateful to him, and the people of Mithila will remain indebted to him for this. This thief writer Pankaj Jha Parashar is a habitual offender. More than a decade ago he found a saviour in Mr Taranand Viyogi who wrote that he (thief writer Pankaj Jha Parashar) gets influenced involuntarily stole others' material in his works. Now he has found another saviour in Kamalananda Jha. The parallel stream is conscious of how Kamalananda Jha takes the leftist side to promote Brahminism and wants to sacrifice social justice. Communism has suffered a lot from people who became communists to escape the land ceiling.
All books by Dinesh Kumar Mishra are now available in the Videha Archive with his permission:
Let us recall here that when Bill Gates was asked whether he was delaying the introduction of the X-Box in India for fear of piracy. His answer was Microsoft never delays the launch of products for fear of piracy. We will continue enriching Videha Archive (http://www.videha.co.in/archive.htm ), despite such risks because not all the fish in the pond rot by some rotten fish in parallel streams. The fishermen here have been and will continue to remove such rotten fish.
The final blow to syndicated pseudo-literary criticism in Maithili.
Original Dinesh Kumar Mishra (Dui Patan Ke Beech Me...
2006): It is noteworthy that between 1923 and 1946, 5,10,000 people died
of malaria, 2,10,000 from Kala Azar, 60,000 of Cholera and 3,000 of
smallpox in the Kosi region (783,000 total deaths).
Thief Pankaj Jha Parashar (Member of Maithili
Advisory Committee of Sahitya Akademi, Delhi) [Jalpranthar 2017
(p. 103)]:
Original Dinesh Kumar Mishra (Dui Patan Ke Beech Me...
2006): On the Kosi River in Bihar, India, a dam was built by King Laxman
II in the 12th century and for this, he received the title of 'Bir' from
the people and the embankment of the river was called 'Bir Dam' The
remains of this embankment are still visible in Supaul district, about 5
km south of Bhim Nagar. Dr Francis Buchanan (1810-11) speculated that
the dam must have been an outer wall built to protect a fort as it
stretched over a distance of 32 kilometres from Tilyuga to its
confluence on the western bank of the Dhaus river. Dr W.W. Hunter (1877)
did not agree with Buchanan's contention that the dam was the protective
wall of a fort. Quoting locals, Hunter believed that most people did not
consider it a fortress wall and according to him it was something else
but he was not in a position to say anything. Yet the common impression
is that it must have been an embankment built along the Kosi River to
prevent the river's current from sliding westwards. People also said
that it seemed that the construction of the embankment had suddenly
stopped.
The pseudo-critic Kamalananda Jha's saviour
of the habitual offender thief Pankaj Jha Parashar quoted the
plagiarised work as follows: (Maithili
Novel, Time, Society and Questions pp. 257-258):
Thief Pankaj Jha Parashar (Member of Maithili Advisory Committee of Sahitya Akademi, Delhi) [Jalpranthar 2017 (p. 31)]:
Original Dinesh Kumar Mishra (Dui Patan Ke Beech Me... 2006): A glimpse of the horrors of the Kosi River can be seen in the event when the army of Feroz Shah Tughlaq returned to Delhi from Bengal. It is said that when the troops of the Sultan reached the banks of the Kosi, they saw that on the other side of the river, the troops of Haji Shamsuddin Ilyas were waiting, ready for a battle. This was the same Haji Shamsuddin who founded the cities of Hajipur and Samastipur. Feroze's troops were stranded on the banks of the Kosi somewhere around Kursela. The speed of the river was preventing them from moving forward. It was finally decided to proceed northward along the river and to locate the water where it was navigable. The troops of the Sultan went up about a hundred kos and crossed the river near Ziaran, situated at the same place where the river descended from the mountains into the plains. The river was thin, but the flow was so fast that heavy stones weighing five hundred manas were floating like straws in the river. On either side of the river where it was found possible to cross it the Sultan erected a row of elephants, and ropes were hung in the bottom row so that if a man loses control he could be rescued with the help of these ropes. Shamsuddin never thought that Sultan's troops would be able to cross the Kosi and when he came to know that Sultan's troops had managed to cross the Kosi, he fled.
Thief Pankaj Jha Parashar (Member of Maithili Advisory Committee of Sahitya Akademi, Delhi) [Jalpranthar 2017 (p. 105)]:
(More screenshots will be updated at this link soon.)
JAGDISH PRASAD MANDAL (POET, NOVELIST AND SHORT-STORY WRITER)
SURVEY OF SOME BOOKS WRITTEN BY SHRI JAGDISH PRASAD MANDAL
SHAMBHUDAS
Jagdish Prasad Mandal injects into the minds of the readers the deity
Barham Baba. He shows that both the devotees as well as Barham Baba
himself are quite cheerful. He shows the convergence of "Shambhua"
(disrespectful calling) into "Shambhu" (respectful calling). And then he
sees Shambhudas changing to Darbaridas.
The crumbling institutions of Mithila and Shambhudas turned to rubble,
which is proof that the arts practised in Mithila have been destroyed.
But the main characters of his other short stories, like Bhaitak Lava or
Bisarh, refused to crumble. So then why has Shambhudas become
Darbaridas? Is it just a simple loss of power? Or is it a change in
Jagdish Prasad Mandal, the writer, himself? Has he become tired; is he
being defeated?
Looking closer we find that Shambhudas is not in any way inferior to the
heroes and heroines of Bhaitak Lava or Bisarh. Then why is Shambhudas
losing? Shouldn't he be winning? Why does the writer push him to defeat?
He is the writer, he's God as far as the characters are concerned, why
he is letting the circumstances be such that Shambhudas finds himself in
a losing position?
Jagdish Prasad Mandal's characters are not artificial ones. And that is
why they do not always win on every economic front.
On the economic front, work is done through hands, through labour. But
culture (including literature) is a very delicate handiwork. The
characters of this story get entrenched in this handiwork.
When Jagdish Prasad Mandal's other characters had to fight on the
economic front, they fought like anything, and they triumphed. But to
serve the area of Art, Shambhudas had to migrate (unlike the characters
of Bisarh).
So Shambhudas had to become a courtesan, a court artist. Economically it
was thankless work. But doing this was the only way of true survival in
these changing times, for it represented the survival of Art!
But here also, in what may still be seen as defeat (for economically, it
was), Shambhudas unfurled a flag of revolt.
He decided not to marry. He decided to let go of the possibility of
family life. Shambhudas became Darbaridas not for his economic survival.
Indeed, he certainly is not a utilitarian, but he had to make the
compromise for the sake of the survival of his Art. His decision not to
marry was repentance for this compromise.
The parallel tradition will topple if Art becomes "Darbaridas". If
Shambhudas loses it will be a loss for Mithila. It is not just Jagdish
Prasad Mandal who will lose, it is the entirety of Mithila who will lose
in his defeat.
Will Mithila heed this warning of Shambhudas?
BAJANTA-BUJHANTA
It is a collection of seed stories.
The title seed-story Bajanta-Bujhanta (trans. talking-understanding) is
a story of a parrot, who is Bajanta-Bujhanta. In this collection of seed
stories, there is more symbolism like these than in the writer's other
stories.
In Chaukidari we see a labourer working even in the eighth month of her
pregnancy, by tying a rope around her waist and stomach.
The story Pator he dedicates to the famous seed-story activist Manoj
Kumar Karn (alias Munnaji), and he assigns a piece of symbolism too.
"Like a dark room which has serpents all around, like that are we too".
This moves the seed story further forward. And Samdahi says "Oh, you
have become the listener of the very language of the crow."
TAREGAN
This book lacks complex plotlines or complicated symbols for the simple
reason that it was written to instil good values in children.
But here, the whole story is a symbol. When Subhas Chandra Bose's father
tells him that sleeping on the ground is not enough, it leaves a
remarkable imprint on his mind. What this man did later for India is
known to all. Satya Vidya Bhardwaj says that "Knowledge is bigger than
heaven."
This collection is not only of importance in children's literature. It
expands the horizons of seed stories too.
GEETANJALI
Chalu Uchitpur poem features a place called Uchitpur, where everyone has
the same body language and the same clothing. In this land, there is no
difference between fire and water.
The "new moonlike full moon" tells us many things about the deformed
"bedhab roop".
Yaar Yau is a song of tragedy. It describes everything that has been
washed away in a flood, including the washing away of the spirit and the
sense of existence.
He dedicates the song to Sh. Rajnandan Lal Das's 'Yug-Yug', where he has
described how all doors close when one is entrapped in a spiderweb.
This complete collection of the song is dedicated to Professor Udaya
Narayana Singh Nachiketa'. All the songs in this collection are lyrical.
RAIT-DIN
Baba did not understand the mischief of the barren trees. He tilled and
ploughed and planted the trees. But then those trees became the abode of
dead souls. They did not touch the soil, reaching the sky by holding the
top.
Halluk Kaaj (trans. easy work) details the technicalities of labour
tools which make the work easy. It is an experience of satisfaction that
the artists get after the completion of their work. How a world full of
empathy is created, it describes that too.
Whether it is in Patta Chhimee's syrupy mental level or in "the huge-lad
is condemned", the writer brings new and distinct typical Maithili
verse. It makes Rait-Din distinct.
INDRADHANUSHI AAKASH
We listen as someone sings Nachari (Maithili songs about Lord Shiva
Songs) while fully swinging his voice and body. The spirituals and
supernaturals have found their places. One is assembling (or creating)
and the other is disassembling. The change is a mere game.
The poet is incredibly careful in his selection of words and subjects.
Mystery, disappointment, answers, along with questions and hope, all
keep coming and going.
TEEN JETH EGARHAM MAAGH
In Ghare-Ghare every household is lit up by a diya, but the whole
village is in darkness.
In Kaushal-Jakhain we are told why the land turned barren and how the
dark village ended up in its sorry state.
In Aas Prem Sang, hope returns to the village.
SARITA
Here, Jagdish Prasad Mandal's verse keeps raising questions. It keeps on
questioning.
His poetry shows a painful awareness of facts and constantly brings up
questions, even in its conclusion.
If you compare his poetry with his prose, you will find much more
pessimism in it, unlike his hope-filled prose. The short length of the
poems does not give him time to analyse the questions, to find the
answers. So, he keeps on raising questions and only questions, poking at
the readers to look for the solutions themselves.
This type of verse is an intriguing first for Maithili literature.
ULBA CHAUR: Short Story, ShrutiPublication, New Rajendra Nagar, (New
Delhi), 2013
It is a collection of thirteen short stories, every story of this
collection depicts the ups and downs of life, it investigates the causes
of the problems and puts forward solutions after giving it modernistic
solutions.
ARDHANGINI: Short Story, ShrutiPublication, New Rajendra Nagar, (New
Delhi), 2013
This is a collection of twenty short stories. He depicts vividly the
distress that salaried people face. On the other hand, he compares it
with the jovial life of the agriculturists. At the same time, he takes
head-on the pseudo-beliefs and other social problems faced by the
village people and offers solutions. He underlines the caste-based
occupations and delineates their importance and necessity for
maintaining a good life in villages.
SATBHAIYA POKHAIR: Short Story, ShrutiPublication, New Rajendra Nagar,
(New Delhi), 2013
This book has so far been run into four editions.
BHAKMOR: Short Story, ShrutiPublication, New Rajendra Nagar, (New
Delhi), 2013
The collection has nine short stories. The web ("ojhari") and other
stories deal with the post-1947 period and deal with the degradation of
democratic values and the deformation of public institutions.
NAI DHARAIYE: Novel, ShrutiPublication, New Rajendra Nagar, (New Delhi),
2013
This novel is the fulfilment of the religion of literary creation, which
has been faithfully by the author. It reflects the face of society
through its moving depiction of life.
KRANTIYOG: Short Story, PallaviPrakashan, Nirmali, Supaul, (Bihar), 2017
It contains six stories. The problem of drainage has arisen due to the
construction of highways and link roads, high-plinth buildings, and
houses. The damage to the environment and the problem of flood arising
out of this have been depicted well. The number and area of ponds, well
and orchards are declining. So, the thorny plants have abounded leading
to a loss of harvest.
SUBHIMANI JINGI: Short Story, Pallavi Prakashan, Nirmali, Supaul,
(Bihar), 2018
The author has vividly depicted the third gender problem. An adolescent
Shyama is neither a male nor female, so the people, including the
mother, decide to hand over Shyama to the Kinnars. But the father rose
in favour of the boy and decides to provide him with all such skills
necessary for a respectable life. He gives an example of Lord Shiva who
is called half male and half female (Ardhanarishwar), and of Krishna who
enters the group of females by transforming himself into Shivani. The
mother, seeing the resolve, also comes on the side of her husband.
The problem of other sex, hitherto unknown in Maithili literature, has
come to the attention of the author. Shyama is a child that is
indisputable. Shyama has every right to live a dignified and respectful
life and for that necessary skills are required and would be provided to
him. The siblings convince the mother but after the stories of Shiva and
Krishna are placed before her, she goes in repentance as to why she was
not taught these stories earlier. The third sex, particularly in the
village society, has been shown with a new perspective. Other stories of
the collection also throw light on other aspects for example the issue
of "Mathas" and asceticism in "Babak Bag-Bagiya" and the resolution of
disputes in a village in "Kukurpan". In "Herayal Jingi" the issue of
development in the village post-independence has been described with the
example of Kamalpur village, the issue of caste and faulty development
model has been given a fresh treatment.
Subhimani Jingi (A respectful life) 2018 is a collection of short
stories consisting of eight stories. The second short story is named
Subhimani Jingi, which is the title of the book also. This book was
written between the 23rd of January 2018 and the 9th of March 2018.
Pallavi Prakashan has published this book, Nirmali. A night-long
tri-monthly reading session of short stories (Sagar Rati Deep Jaray) is
held in Maithili at different venues. The 97th such reading session was
held on 24.03.2018 at Berma village in the convener ship of writer Sh.
Kapileshwar Raut. This village happens to be the village of Sh. Jagdish
Prasad Mandal also. On that occasion, this book was launched (released).
All eight stories of this book depict the constant changes in the life
of a village person vividly.
The eight stories of this book consist of:
1. Kekra Lel Kelau: written on 23.01.2018
2. Subhimani Jingi: written on 28 Jan 2018
3. Babak Bag-Bagiya: written on 3 Feb 2018
4. Ab-Tab: written on 7 Feb 2018
5. Agilah: written on 11 Feb 2018
6. Kukurpan: written on 28 Feb 2018
7. Herayal Jingi: written on 5 Mar 2018
8. Asha Par Paani Phir Gel: written on 9 Mar 2018
1. Kekra Lel Kelau:
This short story begins with a conversation among people sitting around
a bonfire on winter days. Bhogilal bhay is an Ayurvedic Doctor who is
not able to keep his health well. His family also became disconcerted,
all his family except his wife migrated to cities. The conversation goes
on regarding the environment and other aspects of the socio-environment
of village people, which has changed for some people who were not able
to cope with it.
2. Subhimani Jingi
The author has vividly depicted the third gender problem. An adolescent
Shyama is neither a male nor female, so the people, including the
mother, decide to hand over Shyama to the Kinnars. But the father rose
in favour of the boy and decides to provide him with all such skills
necessary for a respectable life. He gives an example of Lord Shiva who
is called half male and half female (Ardhanarishwar), and of Krishna who
enters the group of females by transforming himself into Shivani. The
mother, seeing the resolve, also comes on the side of her husband.
The problem of other sex, hitherto unknown in Maithili literature, has
come to the attention of the author. Shyama is a child that is
indisputable. Shyama has every right to live a dignified and respectful
life and for that necessary skills are required and would be provided to
him. The siblings convince the mother but after the stories of Shiva and
Krishna are placed before her, she goes in repentance as to why she was
not taught these stories earlier. The third sex, particularly in the
village society, has been shown with a new perspective.
3. Babak Bag-Bagiya
This short story deals with the issue of "Mathas" and asceticism.
Goverdhan Das was a poor child whose parents died while he was young. He
becomes the successor of Mahant Gokul Das. Through his story, the author
travels to the hinterland and presents the untouched states of village
life. Through his gardens, the Baba was getting remembered but now these
gardens are vanishing due to poor upkeep.
4. Ab-Tab:
The vegetable articles used during the village feast are the medium
through which the author takes the issue of development affecting
village life.
5. Agilah
Pakshadhar's Uncle returns to the village after retirement. Munilal is
his cousin. Munilal's daughter is widowed. Munilal and his daughter
Savitri are the objects through which Pakshadhar wants his reform agenda
to go through.
6. Kukurpan
The method of resolution of disputes in the village is the subject
matter in "Kukurpan". The resolution can be provided only by a person
who is capable of being so.
7. Herayal Jingi
In "Herayal Jingi" the issue of development in the village
post-independence has been described with the example of Kamalpur
village, the issue of caste and faulty development model has been given
a fresh treatment.
8. Asha Par Paani Phir Gel
Lalit is a literate agriculturist. He starts farming sunflowers. Through
his experiments, the author finds space for detailing actual problems
faced by the agriculturists, the ravage of nature and so on.
DEKHL DIN: Short Story, PallaviPrakashan, Nirmali, Supaul, (Bihar), 2018
A family which is lived for three generations in a village and a family
whose second generation has migrated to the town have been compared. The
superiority of the former has been established in the title short story
of the collection.
GAPAK PIYAHUL LOK: Short Story, PallaviPrakashan, Nirmali, Supaul,
(Bihar), 2018
This is a collection of thirteen short stories. The title short story
deals with have depicted the society existing at the time of the
permanent settlement-Zamindars. The resources were held by a few, the
system continued in Independent India. The people started capturing the
lands resulting in litigation. The title short story depicts one such
litigation involving thirty-five people along with Deenbandhu Kaka. On
the day of the judgment of the case, there happened a bus accident which
was carried.
LAHSAN: Novel, PallaviPrakashan, Nirmali, Supaul, (Bihar), 2018
BIRTHMARK (Lahsan): It is a story of a person from a village, who gets
disenchanted with city life, where morality- both social and personal-
has no meaning. It describes vividly the village and city life, and in
that description, one finds no charm in city life for ordinary class
people. Its plot revolves around personal upheavals, but the actual
beauty of the novel lies in its vivid presentation of city and village
life from the point of view of economically lower-class people.
RAHE JOKER PARIWAR: Short Story, PallaviPrakashan, Nirmali, Supaul,
(Bihar), 2020
The loss of livelihood is the major reason for the migration from
Mithila. But the people who migrate include the well-offs also who
migrate for an easier life. So, thirty years ago, despite being well off
Shantinath left Chanpur and migrated to Shati Niketan (Shanti- peace!!)
in search of peace. And even when some people from his village found
him, he had no regret. Unlike his other books, this migration of the
well-off in search for peace compares and depicts the tussle around the
social life of Mithila.
GAMAK JINGI: Short Story, ShrutiPublication, New Rajendra Nagar, (New
Delhi), 2009
This collection of short stories contains nineteen short stories. The
author was given Tagore Literature Award (Sahitya Akademi) for this
book. Every story in this book depicts the hardness of village life. The
people have to bow before natural calamities. However, the people in
these stories rebound without exception and refuse to let down or
migrate.
MAULAYAL GACHHAK PHOOL: Novel, ShrutiPublication, New Rajendra Nagar,
(New Delhi), 2009
It is his first novel which deals with the problem of migration from the
villages. The novelist envisages the rejuvenation of worn-out systems
which will stop migration.
UTTHAN-PATAN: Novel, ShrutiPublication, New Rajendra Nagar, (New Delhi),
2009
Even the laziest can move forward if he has a desire for economic
improvement. Shyamanand brings technology to agriculture. Unity is
essential if one has to stop the breaking of and migration from
villages.
JINGIK JEET: Novel, ShrutiPublication, New Rajendra Nagar, (New Delhi),
2009
The writings which deal with village life are full of negative forces.
The author puts a break on the disappointment arising out of such
negative writings about village life.
TAREGAN: Inspirational Story Compilation, ShrutiPublication, New Delhi,
2010
This is children's literature and is a collection of 111 inspirational
seed stories which includes the gist of some masterpieces from the world
literature curated for the children.
JEEVAN-MARAN: Novel, ShrutiPublication, New Rajendra Nagar, (New Delhi),
2010
The spiritualism in the author comes to the fore, the real life would be
the afterlife.
JEEVAN SANGHARSH: Novel, ShrutiPublication, New Rajendra Nagar, (New
Delhi), 2010
The author compares two villages the Banspura, which he tells us is the
less developed and the Sisauni, which is comparatively more developed.
The comparison is based on the perception of developed and less
developed among the people of the villages, which is the view of the
author as well. The Sisauni people have a middle school, they have their
Public Durga Pooja in their village and the fair is organized there. But
the Banspura people have none of these although they do organize on an
individual basis a 24-hour kirtan and public langars occasionally. But
the Barharba village is more developed than these two villages. They
have a High School, and they organize more public functions. And lo!
Here comes the Katharba village. It is the most developed where besides
the High School, there is a hospital also, and they organize several
other public functions.
BAJANTA-BUJHANTA: Seed Story, Shruti Publication, New Rajendra Nagar,
(New Delhi), 2013
This is a collection of sixty-eight seed stories which has been woven
around different social issues. The ensuing social changes and upheavals
going around the villages at the individual and social levels are the
themes for the stories of this collection.
JAGDISH PRASAD MANDAL: THE PLAYWRIGHT
MITHILAK BETI (DAUGHTER OF MITHILA)
This is a drama dealing with the miserable life of daughters in the
villages of Mithila. There are many forms of discrimination, the author
has chosen the deformation of relations after the marriage of the
female. The reason for it is enshrined in the unequal treatment between
daughter and son from the day he or she is born. The play begins with an
employee strike against inflation. The causes of inflation are a shift
towards jobs as a result of the decline in agriculture which again is
due to smaller land holdings, an increase in charity-like institutions
(e.g., wedding ceremonies. misuse of money) and dowry. Art lovers
despised wealth. Pickpocketing is on the rise. Prohibition on speech,
increase in kidnappings, violence. The moral decline of government
officials increased insecurity due to the weakening of the government
system. The caste, community etc. contributes to the disintegration of
society, thus endangering even honour. Under the influence of cinema and
sports, the new generation is leaving everything behind- clan, family,
and behaviour, and is going crazy in imitation of the outside world. The
imprint of culture in the collapse of feudal lords. Wells and ponds are
the places where women quarrel. Sita is the symbol of Mithila's female
power. Society is under the influence of courts destroying wealth and
morals, giving further rise to mutual quarrels. Lack of self-strength
among youth, boundless patience among women, the influence of society on
children and widows everything has been depicted. The value of an
educated (working) girl is ruined due to dowry. However, women are more
important than men. The new enthusiasm among the new generation of women
can be seen in their Jeal for acquiring new skills.
However, there is one more issue, the issue of feudal addiction has been
depicted through the symbol of cannabis. The new generation is affected.
They are not known for hard work. They believe in luck. The breakdown of
families under the influence of wealth, the generational differences
between father and son and forced marriages of boys and girls are the
result of these. There is fraud in farm transactions, the dual registry
of the same land can be seen, and bribery has gained acceptance. The
parents want their sons to take the bribe. The adverse impact of
multinational companies on agriculture. Dowry is a big issue, tradition
and anti-tradition thoughts have engulfed the newly awakened society.
Society is divided into factions, and the creation of new human
identities is due to new technologies, new thinking and new work. The
influence of multinational culture on families, society and arts and
culture is imminent. Society is changing by changing the system. Money
brings attitude.
All of this has led to the birth of a new society. Ramvilas gives
importance to human beings which is a blow to dowry. The play ends with
ideal marriage.
COMPROMISE
The depicts agriculture and peasant life and the breaking down of the
feudal society. The need for proper arrangements for bringing
agriculture to the centre stage of the new capitalist society and the
depiction of the deteriorating condition of villages due to the flight
of intellectuals and workers has been attempted successfully. The stress
is on the philosophy of cooperation.
JHAMELIYA BIAH (THE PROBLEMATIC MARRIAGE)
The play deals with various external influences that are seen in the
process of marriage rituals in Mithila. Controversies and conflicts
arise due to external influences. So, the discussion on the disputes
tries to solve the marriage process as a puzzle.
BIRANGNA (THE SHE WARRIOR)
The influence of the market in the orientation of rural life, the
exploitation by the capitalist class through cheap labour and as a
result one is ready to do the lowest thing for the sake of money.
TAMAK TAMGHAIL (THE COPPER VESSEL)
The disintegrating family, customs and relationships can be seen in our
feudal society which itself is disintegrating. The financial base of the
family is in fragmentation.
SATMAAYA (THE STEPMOTHER)
No relationship is faulty but that cannot be said of human behaviour and
thoughts. The ideal form of 'stepmother' is presented through these
concepts.
KALYANI
The depiction of women's awakening through the mention of awareness
towards day-to-day injustice delineates the basic problems. But the
highest price has to be paid in the process.
SAMJHAUTA (AN AGREEMENT)
The description of the fundamental problems of agriculture along with
solutions has been done intricately.
FIVE SHORT STORIES BY SH. JAGDISH PRASAD MANDAL
Sh Jagdish Prasad Mandal has adjudged the following five short stories
as his best:
The Transmission (Sancharan)
The Favourite Work (Bhari Man Kaaj)
The Gone Hope (Aayal Aasha Chali Gel)
The Gift of Life (Jeevan Daan)
On My Behalf (Appan Sati)
The Transmission (Sancharan): The philosophical musings of the life of
Jeebachh Uncle have been depicted with all their splendour. The earthly
comes in between, of course. The flood and the dam, the hope generated
out of the Kosi River project regarding hydel power electricity and the
subsequent despair arising out of its non-fulfilment. The irrigation
facility for the farmers, the arrival of fertilisers, the projects
leading to disturbance in the flow of small rivers, the memory of
earlier mango plantations in villages, and the rain-based agriculture,
all have been dealt with in detail. After fifty Jeebachh Uncle
dissociated from the family life dispassionately and handed over the
responsibilities to both of his sons.
The Favourite Work (Bhari Man Kaaj): This story is the story of
Gianchan. He is overwhelmed by his life, but then Sumitlal tells him a
story and he feels relieved.
The Gone Hope (Aayal Aasha Chali Gel): The people of village Rudrapur
are preparing to go to Rameshwaram for a pilgrimage. A discussion ensues
between Hiralal and Motilal.
The Gift of Life (Jeevan Daan): Sumant and his wife is discussing life
in the aftermath of an earthquake. Last week due to the earthquake all
three houses collapsed.
On My Behalf (Appan Sati): This story is a story of a happening village
surrounding the shops at the roundabout. The people and their
priorities, minor squabbling and all are witnessed here.
Sh. Jagdish Prasad Mandal is known for giving Maithili stories which
directly cater to the problems and solutions of the people of Mithila.
The solution is there in the midst of the people and whoever finds the
solution is the leader of his stories. And there is always one who finds
the solution. He is better known for his stories which are
anti-migration rather than anti-escapism. However, he has selected the
above five short stories which are philosophical musings. But here also
his priority is the people and their life. He says through Jeebach Uncle
that the life of Jeebach Uncle was grand. So grandeur is not about
money, but it is about the manner people live their lives. This grandeur
of life has been depicted not through the lives of landlords but through
the life of common people, who faces drought, flood, and negative
results on the environment through the concept of neo-development, yet
their demeanour is grand.
VERSE WRITING- JAGDISH PRASAD MANDAL
The poems of Jagdish Prasad Mandal started getting published in Videha
eJournal (www.videha.co.in ) and were later print-published as
anthologies. His poems can be categorized under Philosophical, Temporal
(Socio-Economics), Literary, Social, Revolutionary, Historical & General
categories.
PHILOSOPHICAL POEMS
The following poems fall under this category:
MANA-MANI, CHALA RE JEEVANA, SAASU-PUTOHOO VAARTAA, BAURAAELA BATOHEE,
APANE PARA HANSAI CHHEE, O DINA, DHOBI GHAATA, SAANJHA, SAATVIKA BHAVA,
DIVYA SHAKTI, URIAAELA CHIRAI, RANABHOOMI, SAANA-DHAARA-DHAARAA,
SATEE-BESHYAA, PAPEEHAAKA GEETA, VISHADHARAKA BEEKHA, MITHILAA KEHENA,
MAUSAMAKA MUSKEE, AASHAA, AANKHI, MADHURASA, BEEAA, MAHAJAALA, BAATA,
DABHIAAELA DAGARA, LAJJAITA, GANGAA VANDANAA, GANGA SNAANA, GANGAA
NAHAAE, PHANAKEE, ANHARAAELA CHHEE, SABHA KICHHU CHHAI JAALEME, GODHANA
POOJAA, MAATIKA PHOOLA, JHAGARAA, NAJARI, KAMALA DHAARA, BAALA KAVITAA,
BHABHOOTA, JHOOTHA-SAANCHA, NAVA DUNIYAAN, AARATEE, PUROOSHAARTHA,
SARASVATEE VANDANAA, BHEERA-BHAARA, SARASVATEE HAMARA.
O Dina vividly portrays fear arising out of a situation in difficult
times, when one comes to know who their real friends are. Dhobi Ghaata
is an imagery and life has been compared with it. Saanjha says that in
life there is no evening, everything goes on at its speed. Saatvika
Bhaava is a discussion on the true nature of mankind. Divya Shakti
discusses divine power. Uriaaela Chirai is the symbol of the flying
nature of mankind. Ranabhoomi compares theatre with the life of humans.
Saana-Dhaara-Dhaaraa says that the dynamics of the individual buttresses
dynamism in the family. Satee-Beshyaa describes the life of a chaste
woman and a prostitute. Papeehaaka Geeta discusses life and death
through the symbolism of a singing bird. Vishadharaka Beekha is the
poison of a venomous snake, and it has been compared with the obstacles
of life. Mithilaa Kehena is regarding countryside Mithila. Mausamaka
Muskee compares seasons with the ups and downs of life. Aashaa is
regarding hope in life. Aankhi compares the eye with other organs of the
body. Madhurasa places the existence of life under the lens through the
symbol of honey. Beeaa is a seed that has in it the hope and existence
of life. Mahajaala compares the old pond with the old lifestyle and
behaviour. Baata is a way of life which one has to create for oneself.
Dabhiaaela Dagara is the thorny road through which one has to tread.
Lajjaita is honourable life a respectable one.
Jagdish Prasad Mandal has written a few poems under the heading Song
(Geeta) wherein he describes the sorrows, the revolving wheel of time,
and how tough work can be made simple. He laments how humans are not
treating their fellow humans in an egalitarian way as well as the art of
thinking and understanding.
Under his Ganges songs is Gangaa Vandanaa where he describes the Ganges
inside one as compared to the Ganga river. In Ganga Snaana he compares
the Ganges to ideological and Social parlance, in Gangaa Nahaae he
describes the psyche of people revering to the Ganges. Phanakee
describes the impulse under which even the clever get entangled.
Anharaaela Chhee describes the chimaera when a wrong act seems correct
under the wrong regimen. Sabha Kichhu Chhai Jaaleme says that everyone
is estranged and deep down in the quagmire of the system. Godhana Poojaa
describes the ways of the Goddess of wealth (Lakshmi) and Goddess of
Learning (Saraswati). In Maatika Phoola he finds the smell of soil like
a flower. Jhagaraa is a question-answer session of Lor Shiva and Goddess
Parvati. Najari is a question-answer session between eye and viewpoint.
Kamalaa Dhaara is a description of the Kamala river. Baala Kavitaa
Najari is a question-answer session between the father and the son.
Bhabhoota is a description of hegemony. Jhootha-Saancha says that to
defend a lie one has to create hundreds of lies. Nava Duniyaan says that
one oneself has to create one's world. Purooshaartha describes the true
and pseudo aims of life. Sarasvatee Vandanaa vows to remain in an
ever-awakened stage. Bheera-Bhaara exhorts one to walk through one's
strength. Sarasvatee Hamara describes Goddess Saraswati who understands
the sorrows of one and all.
TEMPORAL (SOCIO-ECONOMICS) POEMS
The following poems fall under this category:
AGAHANA, KENAA MET'ATA GAREEBEE, BAARHIKA SANESA, AGO-LORAHAA,
HATHIYAAKA JHATAKEE, RAHASAA CHAURA, BEROJAGAAREE, LEERHEE POKHARI,
BAKAREE BHERAAREE, MAHAGEE, JARANABICHHANEE, NAVA-PHALA, ANDEEKA
CHHAAHARI, POO-BHARA, UNNATI- KISAANEE JEEVANAKA VIKAASAME BAADHAAKA
KAARANA, CHAUREE DHAANAKA KATANEE, KISAANA- TOOTAITA JINAGEE.
Agahana portrays the harvesting season. Kenaa Metata Gareebee describes
the deserted cultivable land due to the condition of the poor. Baarhika
Sanesa describes the gift of the flood like the waterborne plants and
animals.
Ago-Lorahaa is the leftover harvest.
Hathiyaaka Jhatakee is the description of a season when wind accompanies
rain. Rahasaa Chaura is a vivid description of the lowland. Berojagaaree
says unemployment is a created problem. Leerhee Pokhari is a description
of lichen filled pond and society has been compared with it.
Bakaree Bheraaree is the excreta of a goat, which is so fertile that it
can feed plants. Mahagee describes a phenomenon when a big family was a
boon but due to inflation it is now not considered so. Jarana Bichhanee
is the people who collected fuel wood from the wild, whose condition is
very bad and who do not have got any benefit out of independence.
Nava-Phala describes new kinds of work being undertaken by modern-day
families.
Andeeka Chhaahari contrasts flood-raved vegetation with the vegetation
of the desert. It also describes sandy terrain in both areas.
Poo-Bhara is a talk between son and mother when the son is set to leave
his place for livelihood. Unnati deals with obstacles and problems in
the life of people who want to live their life practising agriculture.
Chauree Dhaanaka Katanee is a description of the difficulty in the
harvesting of paddy in lowland knee-down water-filled land. Kisaana
compares the life of farmers through the ages. Tootaita Jinagee
describes hopelessness in life.
LITERARY POEMS
The following poems fall under this category:
KAVITAA, BOORIBAKEE
Kavitaa describes a new preface, new direction and new way for the poem.
Booribakee describes changing the meaning of foolishness in different
situations.
SOCIAL POEMS
The following poems fall under this category:
GAACHHEE BHUTAAI, BHUTAAHI GAACHHEE, BEETALA BARKHAKA VIDAAI,
SANGEE,BETHAA, DHABBAA, PITRIPAKSHAKA BHOJA, THANAKAA, JHAPAASAA,
SHIVACHARANA, CHAUTHACHANDRAKA CHHAAMCHHEE, BHARADUTIYAA, DOOJAA BHAAVA,
BAALA GEETA, PHOOSI, CHIKKANI MAATI, JHAAROO-BAARHANI, DAGAREEKA DAGARA,
CHAPARAASEE BHAAYA, NOTA, LATUAA.
Gaachhee Bhutaai exhorts to demolish the way of life coming through
tradition.
Bhutaahi Gaachhee reasons for the breakdown in family and society. In
Beetala Barkhaka Vidaai the arrival of the new year has been compared
with the ups and downs of life. Sangee says it's time to leave the
friends. Bethaa explores the identity so that reason for sorrow can be
found. Dhabbaa is spot an unblemished record due to some bad acts.
Pitripakshaka Bhoja deals with the question of caste. Thanakaa describes
thunder. Jhapaasaa is warning not to come under the ill influence.
Shivacharana became a good farmer in Shivacharana. Chauthachandraka
Chhaamchhee deals with potters making earthen articles even in the rainy
season for the festivals, but still people not giving credit to them.
Bharadutiyaa describes the festival of brother and sister. Doojaa Bhaava
describes the father and children relationship. Baala Geeta exhorts to
build a new life. Phoosi deals with the habit of telling lies. Chikkani
Maati is a fine-grained soil used to make earthen lamps in the Diwali
festival, the mother-son duo is talking about that. Jhaaroo-Baarhani is
regarding the use of cleaning equipment. Dagareeka Dagara is blowing the
winnowing basket for warding off poverty on the morning of the Diwali
festival. Chaparaasee Bhaaya is regarding a salaried person. Nota is an
invitation to feast when either everyone from the families or one person
per family is invited. Latuaa deals with life where nothing is more than
just enough.
REVOLUTIONARY POEMS
The following poems fall under this category:
JEEBAILE LARAE PARATA, EKAISAMEE SHADEEKA DESHA, PARADESHEE,
Jeebaile Larae Parata says that for life one has to fight. Ekaisamee
Shadeeka Desha depicts a 21st-century country. Paradeshee describes the
motherland through the twelve months.
HISTORICAL POEMS
The following poems fall under this category:
PAICHHALAA GANITA, OMANA SENSE
Paichhalaa Ganita compares old and new mathematics.
GENERAL
The following poems fall under this category:
MADHUMAACHHEE, JUAANEE, TARANGA, AI PARHABASAM' MURAKHE RAHITAUM,
NANGARAKAT'A GHORAA, GEETA, PHOOLABATIYAA, KARAILAAKA PHOOLA,
GIRAHAKATA.
Madhumaachhee compares the life of a honeybee with that of mankind.
Juaanee describes youth. Taranga is the depiction of inner emotions. Ai
Parhabasam Murakhe Rahitaum laments education which does not help in
employment. Nangarakata Ghoraa is a tailless horse who is like a man
having faith in none. Under Songs, there are a few poems which describe
the spring season and life of honesty. Phoolabatiyaa is a nascent seed
plant and it has been compared with the hope that life has. Karailaaka
Phoola is a bitter gourd but its flower smells pleasant. Girahakata is
the fraud who is omnipresent in the system.
THE EPILOGUE: ERA BEFORE AND AFTER: LITERARY SCENE IN MAITHILI AFTER THE
ARRIVAL OF JAGDISH PRASAD MANDAL
Amartya Sen wrote about the famine of Bengal (1942-43), talking about
how lacs and lacs of people died in that famine (15 lacs as per
estimates of the Famine Enquiry Commission), but that this did not
include his loved ones. Likewise in 1967, there happened a great famine
in Mithila. When Indira Gandhi (then the Prime Minister of India)
visited the area, she was shown how the people from the Mushhar
community survived simply by eating bisarh (roots of lotus and other
plants).
But this tragedy was written about only in 2009 by Sh. Jagdish Prasad
Mandal, over forty years after it happened. And the reasons for that
delay are obvious. In Maithili literature, there is a lopsided tendency
which has made its journey slanted and ugly. The ones writing for
mainstream Maithili literature have had no firsthand experience of
tragedies of this magnitude, so they could never write on such subjects.
The coming of Jagdish Prasad Mandal on the literary scene simultaneously
started a renaissance and a reformation movement in Maithili literature.
It commenced a shiny new era. He gets credit for correcting the dark and
ugly course the literary scene had taken. He gets credit for filling the
gap and correcting the lopsided course of Maithili literature, which was
hitherto moving on a one-way road.
Jagdish Prasad Mandal is an artist. He can convey the facts in such an
amazing way that the reader is left in a trance.
He can present the facts directionally and purposefully. Armed with this
ability he has defined the literature of the Maithili language so
greatly that we could bifurcate its history into two eras: the era
before Jagdish Prasad Mandal, and the era which comes after.
His facts are collated from every section of society. They are not
placed in his prose as ornaments. Instead, they flow naturally.
It is as if a high tide has shaken the coastlines of the so-called main
drain of Maithili literature, which dies completely but then regains its
shape during the monsoon.
His words never present a lament. His writing never shirks from its
responsibilities. No matter what hardships they face, the characters
never lose hope or blame their lack of resources; they never grow dismal
and resolutely keep marching on.
He has respect for the lifestyles and contributions of every stratum of
society, and that is very exceptional. This becomes effective because
there is no mismatch between his words and his deeds, and this is
because of the greatness of his personal and social life. What he
thinks, what he does, and what he writes. It makes his literature
truthful.
The ups and downs of the lyrical voice of the Maithili language
attracted even the great Yehudi Menuhin who, in a BBC programme, said it
was one of the sweetest languages. He talked of how his entire body
swung hearing this language. Jagdish Prasad Mandal uses the ups and
downs of this lyrical/rhythmic language to show the affinity of mutual
dependence with its society and culture.
This will bring revolution not only in literature but also in the
economic arena.
अपन
मंतव्य
editorial.staff.videha@gmail.com
पर पठाउ।